Search results

1 – 10 of 12
Expert briefing
Publication date: 3 April 2023

The name of Moldova’s official language has been a matter of controversy for decades. Opponents of the change view it as a step towards the country’s reunification with…

Executive summary
Publication date: 11 May 2018

HUNGARY: Orban hopes to be still in office in 2030

Expert briefing
Publication date: 10 February 2020

Tensions have risen since Syrian government shelling killed seven Turkish soldiers and a civilian contractor in north-western Syria on February 3. Although President Recep Tayyip…

Expert briefing
Publication date: 11 March 2022

The changes, which shocked Scholz's coalition partners, promise a major shift in Germany's strategic posture, with more military capability and a stress on building Europe's hard…

Executive summary
Publication date: 8 October 2020

RUSSIA: Kremlin will not alter Navalny stance

Expert briefing
Publication date: 24 February 2022

Concerns over energy supply from Russia increase the chances that inflationary pressures will persist throughout 2022, potentially worsening the cost-of-living crisis in many…

Expert briefing
Publication date: 26 June 2019

Structural challenges to EU foreign policy.

Expert briefing
Publication date: 9 November 2016

The Turkish leadership believes that a new US administration may stand back from its predecessor's criticisms of Turkey and be better placed to strike a deal with Russia and…

Expert briefing
Publication date: 13 October 2015

While the election was flawed and failed to meet international standards, this year's poll has not so far seen a repeat of the violent crackdown witnessed in 2010. However…

Expert briefing
Publication date: 25 November 2015

The Commission's progress report for Serbia.

Access

Year

Content type

Refine By Country
{"B":[{"count":"1","title":"Belarus","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Belarus%22"}],"C":[{"count":"3","title":"China","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22China%22"},{"count":"1","title":"Croatia","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Croatia%22"}],"F":[{"count":"7","title":"France","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22France%22"}],"G":[{"count":"12","title":"Germany","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Germany%22"}],"H":[{"count":"1","title":"Hungary","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Hungary%22"}],"I":[{"count":"1","title":"Iran","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Iran%22"},{"count":"1","title":"Iraq","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Iraq%22"},{"count":"3","title":"Italy","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Italy%22"}],"K":[{"count":"1","title":"Kosovo","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Kosovo%22"}],"L":[{"count":"2","title":"Libya","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Libya%22"}],"M":[{"count":"1","title":"Moldova","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Moldova%22"}],"N":[{"count":"1","title":"Netherlands","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Netherlands%22"}],"P":[{"count":"1","title":"Poland","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Poland%22"}],"R":[{"count":"1","title":"Romania","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Romania%22"},{"count":"12","title":"Russia","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Russia%22"}],"S":[{"count":"1","title":"Serbia","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Serbia%22"},{"count":"1","title":"Spain","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Spain%22"},{"count":"2","title":"Syria","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Syria%22"}],"T":[{"count":"3","title":"Turkey","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Turkey%22"}],"U":[{"count":"2","title":"Ukraine","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22Ukraine%22"},{"count":"2","title":"United Kingdom","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22United+Kingdom%22"},{"count":"3","title":"United States","url_remove":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22&p=1","url":"q=%28content-type%3Aoxan-article+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-executive-summary+OR+content-type%3Aoxan-graphic-analysis%29+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22foreign+policy%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22politics%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22social%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Germany%22+AND+keyword-topical%3A%22opposition%22+AND+keyword-geographic%3A%22Russia%22+AND+keyword-country%3A%22United+States%22"}]}
1 – 10 of 12