Prelims

Suddhabrata Deb Roy (University of Otago, New Zealand)

‘Natural’ Disasters and Everyday Lives: Floods, Climate Justice and Marginalisation in India

ISBN: 978-1-83797-854-0, eISBN: 978-1-83797-853-3

Publication date: 8 October 2024

Citation

Deb Roy, S. (2024), "Prelims", ‘Natural’ Disasters and Everyday Lives: Floods, Climate Justice and Marginalisation in India (Diverse Perspectives on Creating a Fairer Society), Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. i-xviii. https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-83797-853-320241009

Publisher

:

Emerald Publishing Limited

Copyright © 2024 Suddhabrata Deb Roy


Half Title Page

‘Natural’ Disasters and Everyday Lives

Series Page

DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES ON CREATING A FAIRER SOCIETY

A fair society is one that is just, inclusive and embracing of all without any barriers to participation based on sex, sexual orientation, religion or belief, ethnicity, age, class, ability or any other social difference. One where there is access to healthcare and education, technology, justice, strong institutions, peace and security, social protection, decent work and housing. But how can research truly contribute to creating global equity and diversity without showcasing diverse voices that are underrepresented in academia or paying specific attention to the Global South?

Including books addressing key challenges and issues within the social sciences which are essential to creating a fairer society for all with specific reference to the Global South, Diverse Perspectives on Creating a Fairer Society amplifies underrepresented voices showcasing Black, Asian and minority ethnic voices, authorship from the Global South and academics who work to amplify diverse voices.

With the primary aim of showcasing authorship and voices from beyond the Global North, the series welcomes submissions from established and junior authors on cutting-edge and high-level research on key topics that feature in global news and public debate, specifically from and about the Global South in national and international contexts. Harnessing research across a range of diversities of people and place to generate previously unheard insights, the series offers a truly global perspective on the current societal debates of the 21st century bringing contemporary debate in the social sciences from diverse voices to light.

Previous Titles

  • Disaster, Displacement and Resilient Livelihoods: Perspectives from South Asia edited by M. Rezaul Islam

  • Pandemic, Politics, and a Fairer Society in Southeast Asia: A Malaysian Perspective edited by Syaza Shukri

  • Empowering Female Climate Change Activists in the Global South: The Path Toward Environmental Social Justice by Peggy Ann Spitzer

  • Gendered Perspectives of Restorative Justice, Violence and Resilience: An International Framework edited by Bev Orton

  • Social Sector Development and Inclusive Growth in India by Ishu Chadda

  • The Socially Constructed and Reproduced Youth Delinquency in Southeast Asia: Advancing Positive Youth Involvement in Sustainable Futures by Jason Hung

  • Youth Development in South Africa: Harnessing the Demographic Dividend edited by Botshabelo Maja and Busani Ngcaweni

  • Debt Crisis and Popular Social Protest in Sri Lanka: Citizenship, Development and Democracy Within Global North–South Dynamics by S. Janaka Biyanwila

  • Building Strong Communities: Ethical Approaches to Inclusive Development by Ifzal Ahmad and M. Rezaul Islam

  • Family Planning and Sustainable Development in Bangladesh: Empowering Marginalized Communities in Asian Contexts by M. Rezaul Islam

  • Critical Reflections on the Internationalisation of Higher Education in the Global South edited by Emnet Tadesse Woldegiorgis and Cheryl Qiumei Yu

  • Exploring Hope: Case Studies of Innovation, Change and Development in the Global South edited by Marcelo Sili, Andrés Kozel, Samira Mizbar, Aviram Sharma and Ana Casado

  • Social Constructions of Migration in Nigeria and Zimbabwe: Discourse, Rhetoric, and Identity by Kunle Musbaudeen Oparinde and Rodwell Makombe

  • Rural Social Infrastructure Development in India: An Inclusive Approach by M. Mahadeva

  • Globalization and the Transitional Cultures: An Eastern Perspective by Debanjana Nag

Forthcoming Titles

  • Gender and Media Representation: Perspectives from Sub-Saharan Africa edited by Margaret Jjuuko, Solveig Omland and Carol Azungi Dralega

  • Neoliberal Subjectivity at Work: Conduct, Contradictions, Commitments and Contestations by Muneeb Ul Lateef Banday

  • The Emerald Handbook of Family and Social Change in the Global South: A Gendered Perspective edited by Aylin Akpınar and Nawal H. Ammar

  • An Introduction to Platform Economy in India: Exploring Relationality and Embeddedness by Shriram Venkatraman, Jillet Sarah Sam and Rajorshi Ra

  • Unearthing the Institutionalised Social Exclusion of Black Youth in Contemporary South Africa: The Burden of Being Born Free by Khosi Kubeka

Title Page

‘Natural’ Disasters and Everyday Lives: Floods, Climate Justice and Marginalisation in India

BY

SUDDHABRATA DEB ROY

University of Otago, New Zealand

United Kingdom – North America – Japan – India – Malaysia – China

Copyright Page

Emerald Publishing Limited

Emerald Publishing, Floor 5, Northspring, 21-23 Wellington Street, Leeds LS1 4DL.

First edition 2024

Copyright © 2024 Suddhabrata Deb Roy.

Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited.

Reprints and permissions service

Contact: www.copyright.com

No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying issued in the UK by The Copyright Licensing Agency and in the USA by The Copyright Clearance Center. Any opinions expressed in the chapters are those of the authors. Whilst Emerald makes every effort to ensure the quality and accuracy of its content, Emerald makes no representation implied or otherwise, as to the chapters’ suitability and application and disclaims any warranties, express or implied, to their use.

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

ISBN: 978-1-83797-854-0 (Print)

ISBN: 978-1-83797-853-3 (Online)

ISBN: 978-1-83797-855-7 (Epub)

Dedication Page

For the 181 people who lost their lives during the 2022 Assam floods, 56 from the Barak Valley, and 45 of them being from Silchar.

Contents

List of Figures xi
About the Author xiii
Preface xv
Acknowledgements xvii
Introduction 1
Chapter 1: Disastrous Outcomes of Repressive Monuments 21
Neoliberal Weakening of the State 26
Misplaced Trusts and the State 36
Monumental Amalgamations During Disasters 42
Chapter 2: The Ravages of Relief Activities 53
Struggles within Relief Camps 55
Desperate Acts of the Desperate Classes 63
Disruptions to Life and the Sustenance of Inequality 72
Chapter 3: Disaster Capitalism and the Omnipresent Market 79
A Society of the Market 80
The Emergence of Petty-Disaster Capitalism 88
Disaster Capitalism, Corruption, and Peri-Urban India 98
Chapter 4: Disasters and Everyday Life on Trial 103
The Emergence of NGOs during Disasters 104
The Objectification of Lives 111
Capital’s Routines and ‘Natural’ Disasters 117
Chapter 5: Local Politics, Right to the City, and ‘Natural’ Disasters 125
Localism and NGOs 127
Communitarianism, Municipalism, and ‘Natural’ Disasters 135
Disasters and the Right to the City 139
Chapter 6: Towards a Humanist Politics of Climate Change 151
References 165
Index 183

List of Figures

Fig. 1. The Barak River During the 2022 Floods. 4
Fig. 2. Submerged Areas of Silchar During the 2022 Floods. 5
Fig. 3. View of Silchar Lanes During the 2022 Floods. 6
Fig. 4. A Tunnel on the Silchar–Guwahati Road During the 2022 Floods. 8
Fig. 5. A Massive Traffic Jam on the Silchar–Karimganj Road During the 2022 Floods. 9
Fig. 6. View of an Inundated House During the 2022 Floods. 18
Fig. 7. An Inundated Road at Janiganj. 23
Fig. 8. A Photo From Public School Road During the 2022 Floods. 28
Fig. 9. River Water Flowing Into Kodomtola During the 2024 Floods. 31
Fig. 10. A Child Whose Hand Had Been Fractured While Being Evacuated By His Mother During the 2024 Floods. The Mother Had to Wait Two Days for Being Able to Obtain Adequate Medicines Due to the Floods. 45
Fig. 11. A Poster Advertising Paid Mineral Water Bottles for Being Sold at Heightened Prices on Social Media During the Initial Days of Flooding. 47
Fig. 12. A Boat in Operation During the 2022 Floods. 51
Fig. 13. A Relief Camp in Silchar During the 2022 Floods. 54
Fig. 14. Inside View of a Relief Camp During the 2024 Floods. 59
Fig. 15. Documents Destroyed By Floods in Silchar. 67
Fig. 16. Buckets and Tubs Line Up to Get Water From a Private Tap. 72
Fig. 17. A Helicopter Carrying Relief Materials in Operation During the 2022 Floods. 86
Fig. 18. Dirty Water in People’s Homes During the Floods. 94
Fig. 19. A Person Walking Through a Flood-Affected House to Get Water Bottles. 95
Fig. 20. A Belatedly Registered Relief Camp During the 2024 Floods. 100
Fig. 21. Silchar Authority Helpline Posters Released During the 2022 Floods. 106
Fig. 22. People Flocking to Annapurna Ghat to Check Water Levels. 134
Fig. 23. The Flood Cell Office and the River Water Display Board at Silchar. 134
Fig. 24. A Daily-Wage Worker in Action After the Floods. 146
Fig. 25. Sofas and Mattresses Destroyed By Floods, Some of Which Were Handed Over to Dry Cleaners. 147
Fig. 26. Post-Flood Waste in Silchar. 149

About the Author

Suddhabrata Deb Roy is currently a PhD Finalist at the University of Otago, New Zealand. He is the author of four books: Social Media and Capitalism (Daraja Press, 2021), Singing to Liberation (Daraja Press, 2023), Pandemic Fissures (Routledge, 2024) and The Rise of the Information Technology Society in India (Palgrave Macmillan, 2024). His writings have appeared in numerous journals and public forums including Capital and Class, Critique, The Sociological Review and Notes from Below, among others. This is his fifth book.

Preface

This book was conceptualised during the 2022 Silchar floods, when my family and I were entrapped within our house for more than a week with limited food, no mobile connectivity and electricity. The 12 days of uncertainty coupled with the visions of poverty that I saw during that fortnight form the soul of this book. This book should have been completed long ago. However, as I was working part-time while writing this book, the process of writing became a more gruelling one than what it already was. The most difficult part of the entire process was revisiting the difficult times that I had lived through during those fateful days and reimagining the catastrophic visions of human tragedy that the floods had laid bare which continue to haunt me even today.

I was finally able to successfully handover the final manuscript to Emerald in May 2024, specifically sometime during the middle of May. However, as a mentor once told me, it is always a difficult task to chase a moving target and so was the case with this book as well. Merely a day after Emerald sent me the manuscript queries for this book, Silchar was hit by another flood, albeit of a lower magnitude. It became necessary to include the 2024 data in this book because without that, this book would not have been able to demonstrate the argument that I am trying to make. Although this book largely talks about the 2022 floods, there are instances where this book takes recourse to narrating the incidents and stories of people affected by the 2024 floods as well.

The 2022 fieldwork for this book was one of the most challenging fieldwork assignments that I have ever had, largely because I had to conduct fieldwork in a time when there was no electricity, no mobile connectivity and a significant risk of being affected by the floods personally because my own house was under water for around 12 days. In 2024, however, the task was much easier. All in all, writing this book has been an eye-opener for me, because it allowed me to explore deeply into my own everyday reality: a reality of which I might not directly be a part of today but definitely continues to be something which has shaped me and affected my understanding of the society quite deeply.

Acknowledgements

A book like this which speaks directly of real-life and observed experiences can never be completed without the help of others. This book also is no exception to this general rule.

Thanks to my parents for their continued support throughout the process of writing this book.

Thanks to Marcelle for being a superb intellectual mentor and supervisor. A vote of thanks also goes to Simon and Annabel for their continued support.

Thanks to Kevin, Peter, Sandra, Kieran, Grace and Jonas for their voices of support, criticism and constant theoretical and political engagement.

Thanks to Debasreeta for keeping me motivated while writing this book. Thanks to her for helping me during the short 2024 fieldwork for this book as well.

Thanks to Sayan, Suraj, Nelson and Saraswata for their suggestions regarding this book.

Thanks to my friends, colleagues and students, conversations with whom always help me in better analysing an incident or process. The same was the case with this book as well.

Many thanks to Katy Mathers of Emerald, my commissioning editor at Emerald for this book who first told me that this was a project that they would be interested in. Thanks also to Abinaya Chinnasamy and Lauren Kammerdiener of Emerald who stood by me throughout the writing, editing and production process of this book.

At the end, thanks to all those people who shared their stories with me, without them, this book would have never seen the light of day.