Quality Optimisation of Fine Pitch Surface Mount Solder Joints using Taguchi Experimental Design Techniques

Abstract

The use of Taguchi experimental design techniques to examine the effects of package type, solder paste type and solder reflow technique on the quality of fine pitch surface mount IC package solder joints is described. In particular, the effect of the use of ceramic or plastic packages, copper or Alloy 42 leadframes, silver loaded or non‐silver loaded solder paste and infra‐red, laser or hot‐bar reflow on solder joint metallurgical structure, electrical resistance and mechanical strength is evaluated. In addition to these solder joint parameters, an associated visual inspection was used to find the best process parameters to minimise solder balling, bridging etc. and a correlation between paste contacts at placement and solder bridges after reflow was also conducted. The experiment used an L9 array to find the optimum parameters from three factors, each at three levels. An extension to the basic Taguchi array was included in the form of an outer (noise) factor to include the effect of climatic stress on the solder joints under investigation. Response tables separate out the contribution of each factor level to the mechanical strength and electrical resistance of the assemblies. By comparing the response tables before and after climatic testing it is possible to estimate the effect of each factor level on the long‐term quality of the solder joints. It is shown how Taguchi experimental design techniques can be used to minimise the number of experiments required to predict optimum solder assembly process parameters. The accuracy of the prediction is shown by the results of a confirmation run which yielded mechanical strengths very close to those predicted, both before and after highly accelerated stress testing of the solder assemblies.

Citation

Yamada, T., Barrett, J., Doyle, R. and Boetti, A. (1994), "Quality Optimisation of Fine Pitch Surface Mount Solder Joints using Taguchi Experimental Design Techniques", Soldering & Surface Mount Technology, Vol. 6 No. 1, pp. 15-20. https://doi.org/10.1108/eb037850