Strange Fruit: the power of a protest song NCSS trade book investigation

Jill M. Gradwell (Department of History and Social Studies Education, SUNY Buffalo State College, Buffalo, New York, USA)
Jerry Cappello (Department of Learning and Instruction, SUNY University at Buffalo, Buffalo, New York, USA)

Social Studies Research and Practice

ISSN: 1933-5415

Article publication date: 18 October 2022

Issue publication date: 1 December 2022

93

Citation

Gradwell, J.M. and Cappello, J. (2022), "Strange Fruit: the power of a protest song NCSS trade book investigation", Social Studies Research and Practice, Vol. 17 No. 3, pp. 266-273. https://doi.org/10.1108/SSRP-05-2022-0012

Publisher

:

Emerald Publishing Limited

Copyright © 2022, Emerald Publishing Limited


Recommended for grades 3–7.

This plan has been adapted for grades 7 and up.

This plan will require 30–45 min per day over a span of 3 days.

Book summary

Strange Fruit: Billie Holiday and the Power of a Protest Song is an illustrated biography of jazz and blues artist Billie Holiday and the origin of her most famous song, Strange Fruit. Beautifully illustrated by Charlotte Riley–Webb, this book examines how Billie Holiday, a young African-American woman and Abel Meeropol, a son of Jewish immigrants, collaborated to create a song during the Harlem Renaissance era that challenged racism and paved the way for the civil rights movement.

NCSS standards

  1. Time, Continuity and Change

  2. Peoples, Places and Environments

  3. Individual Development and Identity

  4. Individuals, Groups and Institutions

  5. Power, Authority and Governance

Materials

  1. Strange Fruit: Billie Holiday and the Power of a Protest Song

  2. Interactive whiteboard or chart paper

  3. Harlem Renaissance sources

  4. Harlem Renaissance Works Analysis Handout

  5. Wall Walk resources

  6. Wall Walk 3-2-1 Handout

  7. Protest Song/Poem Final Assessment Rubric

Objectives

  1. Students will use the text and primary sources to learn about methods of protest to fight injustices such as lynching and segregation.

  2. Students will create their own protest song or poem about a current injustice.

Procedures

Exploration/introduction

Exploration/introduction objective.

  1. Students will observe and interpret primary sources from the Harlem Renaissance era.

    • Have images of the Cotton Club (https://allthatsinteresting.com/cotton-club#31) in a slide show and 1920s and 1930s jazz/blues music playing when students walk into the classroom. On an interactive whiteboard or chart paper have Billie Holiday's quote posted, “Somebody once said we never know what is enough until we know what's more than enough.”

    • Once seated, ask the students if they know what type of music is being played, who originated it, era it became popularized and if they know any famous musicians/singers of this type of music?

    • Ask students about the Cotton Club slide show and if they know what it was and where it was located. Provide brief history of the Harlem Renaissance and note the Cotton Club was Harlem's premier nightclub during the 1920s and 1930s.

    • Explain to students they are going to learn about one jazz singer from this era named Billie Holiday and direct their attention to her quote. Ask the students if there has ever been a time in their life when they reached a point where they did not think they could take it anymore? Post responses on an interactive whiteboard, chart paper or computer program to create a visual word wall and ask students to identify common themes or patterns of the responses.

    • Have students select one of the issues identified and to think and share with a partner how they would address the situation.

    • Read together the text up until “Two months after leaving Artie's band, Billie got her wish.”

    • Have students re-watch the Cotton Club slide show and ask them how these images better help them to understand Billie Holiday and what she had enough of already? Think-pair-share.

    • Ask students what Billie Holiday did because she had enough; how did she handle her situation? Record answers on the interactive whiteboard or chart paper.

    • Ask students what wish came true for Billie?

    • Read the rest of the text up until “Yeah, but I'll feel it. I'll know it in my grave.”

    • Give each student a copy of the Strange Fruit lyrics. Have the students read it silently. Show the 1959 video of Billie Holiday singing the song (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bckob0AyKCA)

Exploration/introduction assessment

  1. Provide students with a 4 × 6 notecard and ask they record at least three adjectives to describe the emotions they feel after reading and hearing the lyrics. Collect the notecard as an exit slip and explain to the students in the next part of the lesson they will discuss the song, the historical basis for its creation and its lasting impact.

Development

Development objective

  1. Students will analyze primary sources related to the anti-lynching movement.

    • Display the exit slip adjectives the students recorded and project on the interactive whiteboard or chart paper. Have an audio recording of Strange Fruit played at the same time.

    • Ask the students why a 1939 song that evokes such negative or pessimistic feelings is still talked about today? Share Billie Holiday Timeline https://billieholiday.com/billie-holiday-timeline/.

    • Have students read “What happened next” in the text.

    • Have five stations set up around the classroom and at each station have one source from the sources listed in Appendix 1 along with the Strange Fruit lyrics from the text.

    • Divide the class up into five equal groups and have the groups visit each station to review and discuss the source and complementary questions together.

    • Provide each student with the Harlem Renaissance Works Analysis Handout in Appendix 2 to be completed during the station activity.

Development assessment

  1. Ask the class how Harlem Renaissance artists, like Billie Holiday, used their artistic creativity to protest lynching? Students should substantiate their responses using the provided sources they just reviewed.

Closure and expansion

Closure and expansion objective

  1. Students will examine and interpret different forms of protest expression like artwork, songs and poems.

    • Have posted on the walls in the classroom images, songs and poems from the Harlem Renaissance era that capture other issues artists from the era protested. See Appendix 3 for some suggested resources.

    • Share with the class that lynching was just one issue Harlem Renaissance artists protested and that there were many others.

    • Using a Wall Walk, ask students to complete the 3-2-1 activity and to record their responses on the handout in Appendix 4.

Closure and expansion assessment

  1. Using the student responses from the 3-2-1 activity, probe the students and ask them to summarize and clarify the ways in which Harlem Renaissance artists used their creative ability to protest injustices of the era.

Final assessment

The class will brainstorm a list of modern day local, state, national and international injustices. From the teacher approved list of options, students will select one injustice and write the lyrics/verses for their own protest song/poem using the directions and rubric in Appendix 5 for guidance.

Suggested extension activities

  1. Locate other protest songs, poems or artwork for other eras.

  2. Evaluate how contemporary artists have used Strange Fruit.

  3. Trace the history of the federal anti-lynching legislation movement over the last 100 years.

  4. Research how the Emmitt Till Anti-Lynching Act came to be passed in 2022.

Additional references

African American Protest Poetry. available at: http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/tserve/freedom/1917beyond/essays/aaprotestpoetry.htm

Billie Holiday Official Website. available at: https://billieholiday.com/

Britannica Harlem Renaissance. available at: https://www.britannica.com/event/Harlem-Renaissance-American-literature-and-art

Cotton Club Images. available at: https://allthatsinteresting.com/cotton-club#31

History.com Harlem Renaissance. available at: https://www.history.com/topics/roaring-twenties/harlem-renaissance

Jacob Lawrence, Migration Series (Long Version). available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4lgvB5cV5E

Jacob Lawrence, Migration Series (Short Version). available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLC8xRNcJvE

Lynching in America: Confronting the Legacy of Racial Terror. available at: https://lynchinginamerica.eji.org/report/

Selecting Primary Sources that Deal with Difficult Issues. available at: https://primarysourcenexus.org/2015/02/selecting-primary-sources-deal-difficult-issues/

Smithsonian Harlem Renaissance. available at: https://nmaahc.si.edu/explore/stories/new-african-american-identity-harlem-renaissance

Appendix 1

Source A

Aaron Douglas (1934 public mural) “The Idyll of the Deep South”.

https://www.theartstory.org/artist/douglas-aaron/

Source B

Billie Holiday (1939 song) “Strange Fruit”.

Source C

Langston Hughes (1949 poem) “One-Way Ticket”.

https://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/ows/seminars/tcentury/gmigration/Hughes_OneWayTicket.pdf

Source D

Jacob Lawrence (1941 painting) “Panel 15”.

https://lawrencemigration.phillipscollection.org/the-migration-series/panels/15/there-were-lynchings

Source E

Reginald Marsh (1934 political cartoon) “This is her first lynching”.

https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s68q2180

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Sterling Brown (1931 poem) “Strong Men” (second half).

http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/maai3/protest/text11/brownstrongmen.pdf

Claude McKay (n.d. poem) “Tiger”.

https://www.poetryexplorer.net/poem.php?id=10011722

Countee Cullen (1925 poem) “Shrouded in Color” (excerpts).

https://poets.org/poem/shroud-color

Countee Cullen (1934 poem) “Scottsboro, Too, Is Worth Its Song”.

http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/maai3/protest/text11/cullenscottsboro.pdf

Marcus Garvey (1927 song) “Keep Cool”.

https://allpoetry.com/Keep-Cool

Langston Hughes (1940 poem) “The Ballad of the Landlord”.

http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/maai3/protest/text11/hugheslandlord.pdf

Langston Hughes (1930–33 poem) “I look at the world”.

https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poetrymagazine/poems/52005/i-look-at-the-world

Georgia Douglas Johnson (1922 poem) “Prejudice”.

https://margaretstone.commons.gc.cuny.edu/prejudice/

Jacob Lawrence (1941 art) “Bar and Grill”.

https://americanart.si.edu/artwork/bar-and-grill-79031

Jacob Lawrence (1934 art) “Migration Series”.

https://lawrencemigration.phillipscollection.org/the-migration-series

Appendix 4

Wall walk 3-2-1 handout
Name 3 issues these artists are protesting in their works
1
2
3
Name 2 emotions the artists are conveying in their works
1
2
Name 1 question you still have
1

Appendix 5 Protest song/poem final assessment rubric

As a class we brainstormed a list of modern day local, state, national and international injustices. From the final list of modern day injustices, select one injustice you feel strongly about and construct a protest song or poem in a similar fashion to Billie Holiday's “Strange Fruit.” In your song or poem you will describe the injustice, the ways it has been combated and the positive outcomes from ending this injustice. Use the following to craft your work:

Verse/Stanza 1: State the injustice that you have chosen. Explain the injustice and how it began. Be sure to include examples of the injustice you are writing about. (min. 4 lines)

Verse/Stanza 2: Explain ways your injustice has been combated. Some examples may be: protests, legislation, sit-ins, boycotts, leadership and organizations. (min. 4 lines)

Verse/Stanza 3: Describe the positive outcomes from ending this injustice. (min. 4 lines)

Category43210
Content–accuracyContent displayed is accurate to the injustice and relevant to the assignmentContent displayed is mostly accurate to the injustice and relevant to the assignment with some inaccuraciesContent and descriptions are relevant but vague and disjointedContent is irrelevant and not connected to the injustice or the assignmentSong/Poem was not submitted
Required elementsThe song/poem includes all required elements as well as some additional informationAll required elements are included in the song/poemAll but one of the required elements is included on the song/poemSeveral required elements were missing in the song/poem
Use of class timeUsed time well during the class period; focused on getting the song/poem done; never distracted othersUsed time well during the class period; primarily focused on getting the song/poem done and never distracted othersUsed some of the time well during the class period; there was some focus on getting the song/poem done but occasionally distracted othersDid not use class time to focus on the song/poem OR often distracted others
Verse/Stanza–relevanceAll verses and stanzas are related to the chosen injustice and make it easier to understandMost verses and stanzas are related to the chosen injustice and most make it easier to understandSome verses and stanzas relate to the chosen injusticeVerses and stanzas do not relate to the chosen injustice

Corresponding author

Jill M. Gradwell is the corresponding author and can be contacted at: gradwejm@buffalostate.edu

About the authors

Jill M. Gradwell is professor and coordinator of social studies education at SUNY Buffalo State. She teaches courses in history, social studies education and museum education. Her research interests focus on teaching, learning and assessing history.

Jerry Cappello is a veteran secondary social studies teacher. Holding teaching certificates in numerous states, he has worked at six different high schools across the country. Cappello is currently a graduate student at SUNY University at Buffalo pursuing his master's of education in learning and instruction.

Related articles