TY  - CHAP
AB  - Abstract The increasing use of complex, nonfinancial environmental performance measures in managerial decisions motivates consideration of contextual influences that potentially impact managerial judgments in environmental settings. This study extends general evaluability theory (GET: Hsee & Zhang, 2010) to environmental accounting by investigating the combined effects of evaluation mode and incomplete supplemental evaluability information (SEI; e.g., benchmark data) on management decisions. To elaborate, evaluation mode is the display format in which the accounting information system (AIS) provides available information for analysis; e.g., a manager’s or business unit’s performance is assessed either comparatively (i.e., in joint mode) or individually (i.e., in separate mode). GET suggests more decision weight on measures containing SEI in separate mode because that evaluation mode contains less context in which to analyze information. On the other hand, more decision weight should result for measures that do not contain SEI in joint mode because that mode already contains more context for analysis (e.g., comparing multiple performances with each other). To test these predictions, experimental participants (n = 53) evaluated environmental measures for factories with similar environmental performances. To operationalize the information available in many environmental AIS, some, but not all, performance measures contained benchmark data (incomplete SEI); factories were evaluated either jointly or separately. Participants evidenced decision intransitivity; i.e., in separate evaluation mode, factories rated higher when a favorable measure contained SEI, while in joint evaluation mode, factories rated higher when a favorable measure lacked SEI. The results extend previous AIS and management accounting research by investigating contextual influences, and potential systems design elements, in judgments using environmental AIS.
VL  - 20
SN  - 978-1-78714-527-6, 978-1-78714-528-3/1475-1488
DO  - 10.1108/S1475-148820170000020002
UR  - https://doi.org/10.1108/S1475-148820170000020002
AU  - Alewine Hank C.
AU  - Stone Dan N.
PY  - 2017
Y1  - 2017/01/01
TI  - Accounting Systems’ Design Matters: Evaluability and Mode Influence Environmental Performance Judgments
T2  - Advances in Accounting Behavioral Research
T3  - Advances in Accounting Behavioural Research
PB  - Emerald Publishing Limited
SP  - 23
EP  - 62
Y2  - 2024/04/19
ER  -