Two issues in MacLean’s account are the focus on the review. The first is simply a research mistake that she drew unwarranted conclusions from regarding Buchanan’s connection to the “massive resistance” movement against desegregation of Virginia public schools. The second issue reveals MacLean’s unwillingness to consider the changes in Buchanan’s scholarship over his career. Taken together, the issues indicate that she refused to read Buchanan on his own terms in order to understand the progress of his work, even if she disagreed with him at the end.
Emmett, R.B. (2019), "Reading the Hermeneutics of Suspicion with Suspicion: A Review Essay on Nancy MacLean’s
Emerald Publishing Limited
Copyright © 2019 Emerald Publishing Limited