Strategy, Ideology, and Structure: The Political Processes of Introducing the M-form in two Dutch Banks

Abstract

Purpose – The broader aim of the research is to better understand the origins of firm heterogeneity in terms of strategy and structure, looking beyond convergence pressures resulting from economic and institutional forces.

Design/methodology/approach – To identify firm-specific differences, the paper uses an in-depth analysis of two matched cases, comparing the introduction of diversification strategies and decentralized organizational structures in two Dutch banks. Based on detailed archival research it tries to understand how different outcomes were shaped by political processes involving a variety of internal and external actors.

Findings – The research shows the importance of these processes and, in particular, the role of management succession as a trigger for organizational changes as well as the potential power of management consultants based on a combination of their own “political” skills and the opportunity provided by internal divisions. Moreover, the study confirms the view that organizational change requires a change in dominant ideology.

Research limitations/implications – The research was able to go beyond the limitations of extant studies based on cross-sectional data or single cases. It demonstrates the usefulness of historical analysis when examining changes in strategy and structure. Its results need to be confirmed by conducting similar studies in different contexts.

Originality/value – The paper provides new insights into the complex and dynamic processes of organizational change and shows how external consultants – within a specific set of circumstances – were able to manage these processes. The results are valuable to scholars studying organizational change and those looking at consultants and their role. They might also provide insights for practicing managers working or planning to work with consultants.

Citation

Kipping, M. and Westerhuis, G. (2012), "Strategy, Ideology, and Structure: The Political Processes of Introducing the M-form in two Dutch Banks", Kahl, S.J., Silverman, B.S. and Cusumano, M.A. (Ed.) History and Strategy (Advances in Strategic Management, Vol. 29), Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. 187-237. https://doi.org/10.1108/S0742-3322(2012)0000029011