Index
Justification, Evaluation and Critique in the Study of Organizations
ISBN: 978-1-78714-380-7, eISBN: 978-1-78714-379-1
ISSN: 0733-558X
Publication date: 1 June 2017
This content is currently only available as a PDF
Citation
(2017), "Index", Justification, Evaluation and Critique in the Study of Organizations (Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Vol. 52), Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. 399-403. https://doi.org/10.1108/S0733-558X20170000052019
Publisher
:Emerald Publishing Limited
Copyright © 2017 Emerald Publishing Limited
INDEX
Academia
, 252–255
Accounting test
, 226–227
Accounting values
accounting test
, 226–227
compromise and controversy
, 211–220
compromise of worths
, 227–229
compromise situations
, 217–220
empirical settings
, 220–234
managing multiplicity
, 220–226
qualified object
, 214–215
SET
, 229–234
tests of worth
, 215–217
Adversarial discursive strategies
, 161
American pragmatism
, 9
Assess worth
, 245
Boltanski’s justice
, 313–317
Boltanski’s love
, 309–313
Bourdieu-based approach
, 9
Bourdieusian sociology
, 23
Business simulation
, 251–257
Civic world
, 11, 179
Coherentism
, 350
Commercialization trajectory
, 251–252, 257–258
Common good
, 280–281
Common worlds
, 10
Competitions
, 392
Complex domination
, 114–115
financial intermediation
, 131–132
Lemieux’s approach
, 118–120
power
, 134–136
Complex financial domination
, 16
Compromise
, 75, 79, 82
Compromise of worths
, 227–229
Compromise situations
, 217–220
Concern for community, and member benefit
, 89–90
Contemporary societies
, 7, 17
Conventions
legitimate
, 59
sociology of
, 74, 75, 78–79
Co-operation
, 91–92
Co-operatives
, 75, 80, 89
Coordination
, 386–389
Corporate social responsibility (CSR)
, 21, 22
County Agricultural Departments (DDAs)
, 277
County Amenities Departments (DDEs)
, 277
Critical capacities
, 22
Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA)
, 152
Critical sociology
, 6
Critique
, 4, 5, 10, 11, 75, 79, 82
Data analysis
, 82–84, 123–125
Data collection
, 81–82
Democratic debate
, 286–287
Democratic member control
, 84–86
Democratizing critical theory
, 8
Dialogue
conformity to
, 40–43
moral legitimacy emerging
, 56–63
negotiating moral legitimacy
, 52–56
Domestic heritage and quality of life
, 282–283
Domestic world
, 11, 179
Domination
, 112–120, 145, 148, 149
Downscaling energy view
, 194
Early adoption
, 384–386
École des Hautes E´ tudes en Sciences Sociales (EHESS)
, 383
Ecological argument
, 282
Ecological cause, media coverage of
, 284–285
Ecological goods, market value of
, 285
Ecological justification
cover of nature
, 275–278
invocation of nature
, 274–275
nature in polity
, 278–290
polity to ecosystem
, 290–296
Economies
of enrichment
, 20
member economic participation
, 86–89
national economic competiveness
, 146
of worth perspective
, 175
Economies of Worth (EW)
conceptual grammar
, 10–12
intellectual origins of
, 6–10
typology of
, 35
Economies of Worth (Stark)
, 4
Economy of enrichment
, 20
Ecosystem
balance in system
, 293–295
biological integration
, 295–296
biosphere
, 295–296
referent community
, 290–293
Empirical setting
, 79–81
Energy
downscaling energy view
, 194
justified energy
, 191–196
material consequences of
, 177
security
, 156
Energy regimes
energetic foundations of societies
, 180–183
energy problematic
, 183–189
justifications
, 176
re-valuing energy
, 189–196
social science
, 177–180
theory
, 177–180
Energy security
, 156
Environment, industrial efficiency and technical approach to
, 286
Environmental movement, ecological thinking
, 185–186
Ethnomethodology
, 7
Evidentialism
, 350
EW tool box
, 211–220
See also Economies of Worth (EW)
Externalism
, 350
Fetus, engendering
, 327–328
Field-configuring events
, 5
2008 Financial crisis
, 15
Financial intermediation
complex domination in
, 131–132
formatting and impeding critique
, 132–133
grammars of
, 125
internal critique of
, 125–134
natural grammar
, 126–129
public jurisdiction
, 133–134
realistic grammar
, 129–131
Financial intermediation industry
, 120–122
Foundationalism
, 350
Foundherentism
, 350
Fracking
, 144, 145
contestation of
, 160–162
data analysis
, 152–156
vs. justifications
, 156–160
UK parliamentary inquiries into
, 150–152
in United Kingdom
, 149–150
French pragmatist sociology
, 35
French Pragmatist Sociology
, 4, 9, 10, 21
Global Execution Services (GES)
, 122–123, 125
Global politics
, 191–196
Gods, highlight of
, 339
Good of small group
, 279–280
Grammars
, 110, 112, 116–119
conceptual grammar
, 10–12
financial intermediation
, 125
Lemieux’s notion of
, 110
natural grammar
, 126–129
realistic grammar
, 129–131
Green development
, 19
Green order of worth
critical lever
, 287–288
new polity
, 288–289
Green world of worth
, 179
Groupe de Sociologie Politique et Morale (GSPM)
, 383
Hydrocarbon and strategic interests
, 186–187
Industrial-energy regime
, 16
Industrial pollution
, 187–189
Industrial world
, 11, 179
Infinitism
, 350
Innovation
, 13
Inspired world
, 11
Institutional logics
, 76
Interests, generalisation of
, 277–278
Internalism
, 350
Justifications
, 14–16, 145–149
of agreement
, 356–357
of common worlds
, 357–359
concentrated energy enables industrial society
, 181–183
of critique
, 359–362
energy regimes
, 176
and engagements
, 367–368
of ethics
, 352
of existence
, 351
vs. fracking
, 156–160
and hierarchy of goods
, 166–167
of justice
, 352–354
of justification
, 363–368
of perspective
, 354
of practice
, 362–363
of presuppositions
, 355–356
Justified energy
, 191–196
Knowledge commercialization
, 18, 243–244, 244–245
Languages of government
, 276–277
Legitimacy
certainty
, 58–59
scope
, 56–58
See also Moral legitimacy
Legitimacy maintenance
, 5
Legitimate conventions
, 59
Lemieux’s grammars
, 116–118
Love and Justice as Competences (Boltanski)
, 8
Love and violence
Boltanski’s love
, 309–313
erotics of Boltanski’s justice
, 313–317
integral to institutional life
, 320–321
new modes of action
, 306–308
OJ’s mode of action
, 304–306
pathway to justice
, 317–320
return of religious
, 308–309
Management tool
, 257–263
Managerial domination
, 110
Managing multiplicity
, 220–226
Manufacturing
, 13
Market world
, 11
Materiality
, 12
Member economic participation
, 86–89
Missing children
, 326–327
Modernity
, 174, 175, 189
Moral justification
agency and dialogical resources
, 44–47
differential power and capability
, 48
focus on moral
, 44
higher common principle
, 47
investment
, 48–49
moral legitimacy, processual view of
, 48
temporary truces
, 47
See also Justifications
Moral legitimacy
, 14
antagonism creates niche legitimacy
, 62–63
approaches to
, 36–37
communicative approach
, 40–43
compromise
, 52–54
compromise creates fragile legitimacy
, 60–61
external jolts
, 50–51
institutional logics
, 39–40
negotiating antagonism
, 55–56
negotiating transcendence
, 54–55
Parsonian approaches
, 38–39
processual view of
, 48
social movements
, 50
transcendence creates strong legitimacy
, 61–62
types of
, 59–63
uncertainty
, 49–50
unique situations
, 51
Weberian approaches
, 37–38
Moral multiplexity
, 14
National economic competiveness
, 146
Nature
cover of
, 275–278
invocation of
, 274–275
in polity
, 278–290
Neoliberalism
, 137
Net Present Value method (NPV)
, 226
Non-government organisations (NGOs)
, 145
On Justification (Boltanski)
, 4, 8, 10, 110, 384, 386
Orders of worth
, 75, 175, 200
data analysis
, 248–251
data collection
, 248
knowledge commercialization
, 243–244
research context
, 247–248
valuation
, 243–244, 245–247
Organizational phenomena
, 5
Organizational research
, 9
Personal good
, 278–279
Pluralism
, 10, 13, 14
individual responses to
, 76–78
sociology of conventions
, 78–79
vision of
, 74
Political instantiation
, 75
Political instantiations
, 90–91
Political regime
, 162–164
discursive strategies
, 145–149
discursive strategies confirming reality
, 162–164
justifications
, 145–149
Political regimes, domination and
, 167–168
Political theory
, 306
Politics
, 145
domination of
, 149
Power
complex domination
, 134–136
financial organizations
, 137–139
of justification mechanisms
, 136
Power relations
, 110, 111
Pragmatic
, 91–92
Pragmatic approach
, 5
Pragmatic dimension
, 7
Pragmatic instantiation
, 75
Pragmatic sociology (PS)
, 16, 110, 111, 112–113
Pragmatic sociology and power
, 112–113
Production
justice’s absence of
, 321–323
spirit and collection
, 323–326
Professional sociologists
, 8
Promotional discursive strategies
, 160
Protean Defence Associations
, 275–276
Public management contexts, decision-making in
, 5
Public-sphere conversation
, 178
Reality, discursive strategies and confirmation of
, 165
Reality tests
, 146
Reformist
, 91–92
Reformist instantiation
, 75
Relational discursive strategies
, 161
Return of institution
domination
, 329–332
religion
, 335–339
value
, 329–335
Sales and profit
, 13
Satellite imagery changes perception
, 184
Self-reinforcing communicative logic
, 242
Social competences and capacity
, 9
Social construction
, 17
Social contexts
, 350
Social responsibility
, 13
Sociology of conventions
, 76–79
Socio-Pragmatic Perspective
, 20
Soft capitalism
, 210
South West Yarragadee (SWY)
, 228–229
Symmetry
, 11
Synergistic assemblage
, 260–263
Technology transfer office (TTO)
, 259
Tests of worths
, 215–217, 229–232
Theater of representation
, 210
Thévenot’s engagements
, 115–116
Traditional sociology
, 111
Valuation
, 390–393
concept of
, 4
sociology of
, 242
Value creation activities
, 210
World of fame
, 11
- Prelims
- Section I Introduction
- Justification, Evaluation and Critique in the Study of Organizations: An Introduction to the Volume
- Section II Managing Organizational Pluralism: How Individuals Navigate Moral Contradictions and Compromise
- When Orders of Worth Clash: Negotiating Legitimacy in Situations of Moral Multiplexity
- Co-Operatives, Compromises, and Critiques: What Do French Co-Operators Tell Us about Individual Responses to Pluralism?
- Section III Looking at Organizations Critically: Rhetoric, Justification and Criticism-as-Practice
- ‘Public’ Versus ‘Natural’ Grammars: Complex Domination in the Financial Intermediation Industry
- Re-Producing a Neoliberal Political Regime: Competing Justifications and Dominance in Disputing Fracking
- Capital and Carbon: The Shifting Common Good Justification of Energy Regimes
- Section IV Reconsidering Valuation and Evaluation in Organizations
- Accounting Values, Controversies, and Compromises in Tests of Worth
- Commercializing Academic Knowledge in a Business School: Orders of Worth and Value Assemblages
- Section V Pushing the Boundaries of Pragmatic Sociology’s Theoretical Agenda
- An Ecological Justification? Conflicts in the Development of Nature
- The Passion of Luc Boltanski: The Destiny of Love, Violence, and Institution
- Remarks on the Nature of Justification: A Socio-Pragmatic Perspective
- For What It’s Worth
- Index