Multiple Shades of Grey: Opening the Black Box of Public Sector Executives’ Hybrid Role Identities

Abstract

Public sector reforms of recent decades in Europe have promoted managerialism and aimed at introducing private sector thinking and practices. However, with regard to public sector executives’ self-understanding, managerial role identities have not replaced bureaucratic ones; rather, components from both paradigms were combined. In this chapter, we introduce a bi-dimensional identity approach (attitudes and practices) that allows for different combinations and forms of hybridity. Empirically, we explore the role identities of public sector executives across Europe, building on survey data from over 7,000 top public officials in 19 countries (COCOPS survey). We identify country-level profiles, as well as patterns across countries, and find that administrative traditions can account for these profiles and patterns only to a limited extent. Rather, they have to be complemented by factors such as stability of the institutional environment (indicating lower shares of hybrid combinations) or extent of reform pressures (indicating higher shares of hybrid combinations).

Citation

Leixnering, S., Schikowitz, A., Hammerschmid, G. and Meyer, R.E. (2018), "Multiple Shades of Grey: Opening the Black Box of Public Sector Executives’ Hybrid Role Identities", Bureaucracy and Society in Transition (Comparative Social Research, Vol. 33), Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. 157-176. https://doi.org/10.1108/S0195-631020180000033012