Discrimination of blue ballpoint pen inks in Chinese market with confocal Raman microscope

Abstract

Purpose

Ballpoint pen ink analysis is important for forensic scientist which can collect valuable information on questioned document. Inks widely used now constitute many substances to improve needed ink characteristics, including the coloring material (dyes or pigments), inks, solvents and resins. The complex components of the inks confront forensic ink chemists with a big challenge to carry out this analysis. However, because of the great importance of determining whether two pieces of written text originated from the same ink, therefore, comparison of different writing inks on a document to forensic scientist, many techniques have been tentatively employed in the ink analysis. In this study, Raman microscope was employed successfully in the analysis of inks. The paper aims to discuss these issues.

Design/methodology/approach

Damped or wet samples cannot be analyzed by IR if dehydration is not carried out FTIR observation, because of the extremely strong absorbance of water. Raman spectroscopy can cover the shortage of FTIR spectroscopy because water has weak absorbance in Raman spectroscopy. Raman shifts can give extra peak information because it usually has different positions with FTIR spectroscopy. A Renishaw inVia confocal Raman microscope system with two lasers emitting at 532/633 nm, charge-coupled device detector was employed collecting the Raman spectrum. Laser was chosen for emission in 1-100 percent power depending on the proper energy to get signal strong enough and protect the samples from burning. At least triple-tests were performed for each sample.

Findings

The result indicated that Raman spectroscopy could easily remove the interference caused by the paper which could hardly be removed with infrared spectroscopy. No sample preparation was required and only 30 s was needed for each sample in the optimized method. The method proved to be fast, accurate, non-destructive and could be easily applied to the real cases. The primary survey on inks from different market indicated five kinds of inks could be identified. The indicative peaks of each kind of ink (693, 1,150-1,210, 1,280-1,300, 1,360-1,400 and 1,531 cm−1) were summarized. The distributions of the inks in markets were also illustrated. Ink using alkyd resin as connecting materials or copper phthalocyanine as pigment decreased significantly. The data in this study would be helpful for the forensic scientists to identify these inks and examine the questioned document.

Originality/value

No previous studies on the analysis of inks in China market were found to the authors’ best, so the forensic scientists have no idea about the method using Raman for discrimination which proved to be effective, accurate and fast, the indicative peaks of each inks, the distributions in the markets, and therefore, the possibility to encounter specific ink in cases The data in this study would be helpful for the forensic scientists to identify these inks and examine the questioned document.

Citation

Liu, S., Feng, J., Lv, J. and Zhang, W. (2014), "Discrimination of blue ballpoint pen inks in Chinese market with confocal Raman microscope", Pigment & Resin Technology, Vol. 43 No. 1, pp. 45-51. https://doi.org/10.1108/PRT-12-2012-0089