To read the full version of this content please select one of the options below:

Labour economy: do unions really influence sourcing decisions?

Kaylee Boccalatte (Department of Employment Relations, Griffith University, Nathan, Australia)

Journal of Management History

ISSN: 1751-1348

Publication date: 14 August 2019

Abstract

Purpose

This article aims to uncover the influence employment relations, and more specifically union avoidance has on the decision to outsource road transport. Employment Relations literature often attributes outsourcing decision to decollectivist strategies, minimising the influence unions have in their workplaces or to labour cost reduction objectives. These explanations, however, fail to explain why some firms do not outsource when their sourcing structure incurs greater union involvement or industrial relation.

Design/methodology/approach

The author examines two case studies. Company A and Company B, while operating in a similar environment, selling similar products and offering a similar home delivery service have adopted different governance structures for their outbound transport function; Company A has integrated while Company B has outsourced. Was union avoidance or transaction cost reductions central to their respective decisions?

Findings

Company A did not integrate in an effort to circumvent union intervention or reduce costs. Company A’s integration, on the contrary, increased the firm’s dealings with unions, as well as regulatory compliance and transaction costs. Company B’s decision to outsource yielded similar results. While not experiencing an increase in union intervention, the firm failed to reduce the density of unionised labour and by maintaining ownership of delivery vehicles, saw a rise in costs.

Originality/value

Union avoidance is not an explanatory factor in the sourcing decision, nor is it possible to explain through transaction cost economics. Explication for outcomes lies in value enhancement. Companies are willing to incur higher employment relations and transport costs if the result is higher value capture.

Keywords

Citation

Boccalatte, K. (2019), "Labour economy: do unions really influence sourcing decisions?", Journal of Management History, Vol. 26 No. 1, pp. 19-40. https://doi.org/10.1108/JMH-04-2019-0025

Publisher

:

Emerald Publishing Limited

Copyright © 2019, Emerald Publishing Limited