The changing relationships between government bond yields and capitalisation rates: Evidence from the UK, USA and Australia

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to analyse the gap between government bonds (index-linked and long-dated) and real estate yields/capitalization rates over time for the UK, Australia and the USA. The global financial crisis was a sharp shock to real estate markets, and while interest rates and government bond yields fell in response around the world, real estate yields (cap rates) have risen.

Design/methodology/approach

The absolute yield gap levels and their variation over time in the different countries are compared and linked to the theoretical reasons for the yield gap and, in particular, a changing real estate risk premium. Within this context, it assesses whether there have been structural breaks in long-term relationships during booms and busts based on autoregressive conditionally heteroscedastic (ARCH) models. Finally, the paper provides further insights by constructing statistical models of index-linked and long-dated yield gaps.

Findings

The relationships between bond and property yields go through a traumatic time around the period of the global financial crisis. These changes are sufficiently strong to be statistically defined as “structural breaks” in the time series. The sudden switch in the yield gaps may have stimulated a greater appreciation of structural change in the property market.

Research limitations/implications

The research focuses on the most transparent real estate markets in the world, but other countries with less developed markets may respond differently.

Practical implications

The practical implications relate to how to value real estate yields relative to interest rates.

Originality/value

This is the first paper that has compared international yield gaps over time and examined the role of the gap between index-linked government bonds and real estate yields.

Citation

Jones, C., Dunse, N. and Cutsforth, K. (2015), "The changing relationships between government bond yields and capitalisation rates: Evidence from the UK, USA and Australia", Journal of European Real Estate Research, Vol. 8 No. 2, pp. 153-171. https://doi.org/10.1108/JERER-05-2015-0023