The ideological character of accounting textbooks: Insights from Indonesian accounting lecturers

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to explore the perspectives of accounting lecturers regarding the contents of accounting textbooks. It focusses on the ideological character of introductory financial accounting (IFA) textbooks prescribed in the first year of accounting degrees in Indonesia.

Design/methodology/approach

The ideological analysis is informed by Thompson’s (1990) concept of ideology, which was used in a critical sense to refer to its role in serving unequal power relations. Semi-structured interviews of Indonesian accounting lecturers were utilised to collect data.

Findings

In the interviews, the lecturers revealed that the prescribed IFA textbooks focussed on prioritising shareholder interests. The mainstream view among the lecturers was that accounting textbooks realistically exhibited the natural form of accounting, whilst lecturers with an Islamic accounting and finance background notably viewed the character of IFA textbooks as serving an ideological role or permeating propaganda. The latter suggests that alternative worldviews, relevant and nuanced to the Indonesian context, are promoted in accounting education.

Research limitations/implications

The findings presented in this paper should provide a basis for further research into the ideological character of accounting textbooks by analysing the internal structure of accounting textbooks and investigating the broader perspectives of other users and individuals involved in the production of accounting textbooks.

Practical implications

An awareness of the ideological representation of accounting textbooks can provide insights for universities, publishers and policy makers concerned with lecture structure, textbook design and regulation formulation in accounting education.

Originality/value

This is the first paper to empirically explore the ideological character of accounting textbooks prescribed in an Islamic developing country setting.

Citation

Irsyadillah, I. (2019), "The ideological character of accounting textbooks: Insights from Indonesian accounting lecturers", Journal of Accounting in Emerging Economies, Vol. 9 No. 4, pp. 542-566. https://doi.org/10.1108/JAEE-02-2017-0011