Rebels against the system: Leadership agency and curriculum innovation in the context of school autonomy and accountability in England

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to describe and analyse the development of school autonomy, school leadership and curriculum innovation in England over the past 40 years. It provides a baseline picture for the wider international study on school autonomy and curriculum innovation.

Design/methodology/approach

An initial literature review was undertaken, including policy document analysis. Interviews and observations were undertaken with participants on a pilot professional programme for school leaders seeking to develop their school curriculum.

Findings

While all schools in England have needed to adapt their curricula to reflect the new National Curriculum introduced from 2014, relatively few schools appear to have used this opportunity to design genuinely innovative curricula that respond to the changing needs of learners in the twenty-first century. This includes the academies and free schools – currently around one in four schools – which are not legally required to follow the National Curriculum. The authors posit that leadership agency by principals and their professional teams is more important than policy/legal freedoms for securing curriculum innovation. Such agency appears to depend on the capacity and confidence of leaders to shape an alternative and innovative curriculum in the face of structural constraints, in particular England’s sharp accountability system, effectively making these leaders “rebels against the system”.

Research limitations/implications

The empirical findings are preliminary and based on a small convenience sample.

Originality/value

Given England’s position as a relatively extreme example of high-autonomy-high-accountability quasi-market school reforms this paper provides valuable insights on school autonomy and curriculum innovation that can inform policy and practice more widely.

Citation

Greany, T. and Waterhouse, J. (2016), "Rebels against the system: Leadership agency and curriculum innovation in the context of school autonomy and accountability in England", International Journal of Educational Management, Vol. 30 No. 7, pp. 1188-1206. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJEM-11-2015-0148