Performance outcomes in empirical management accounting research: Recent developments and implications for future research

Abstract

Purpose

This paper seeks to further the understanding of the rather fragmented research in the area of quantitative management accounting research. The purpose of this study is to provide a synthesis and an extended discussion of the literature from the performance outcome standpoint and to foster future research in this area by identifying promising recent developments in the assessment of performance outcomes and gaps in the literature.

Design/methodology/approach

A literature analysis was adopted based on empirical studies and literature reviews published in a wide range of journals.

Findings

The overall conclusion of this study is that future management accounting research can still make progress in the measurement of performance outcomes.

Research limitations/implications

Research published in English, and the period of the past decade was emphasized to examine recent frontiers of knowledge. The results imply that increasing and simultaneous analysis of various kinds of performance outcomes could be conducted, ranging from accounting‐based to social and environmental outcomes and relative‐to‐peers assessments in different settings. If possible, development of performance outcomes could be investigated with longitudinal and panel, in addition to cross‐sectional, research designs. Attempts could be made to analyze the nature of causality to advance both management accounting literature and social science research.

Practical implications

This study furthers understanding of behaviorally‐, organizationally‐ and strategically‐oriented management accounting research that has played a central role in assessing to what extent people are likely to succeed with their management accounting and control systems in various settings.

Originality/value

This paper presents a theoretical framework and several examples potentially useful for both academic scholars and practitioners.

Citation

Kihn, L. (2010), "Performance outcomes in empirical management accounting research: Recent developments and implications for future research", International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, Vol. 59 No. 5, pp. 468-492. https://doi.org/10.1108/17410401011052896