Cancellations of elective orthopaedic procedures: Compliance with NHS Modernisation Agency guidelines

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to find the incidence and medical reasons for cancellations of elective orthopaedic cases following admission for an operation in a district general hospital. The paper also aims to determine the deficiencies in the local preoperative assessment protocol.

Design/methodology/approach

This is a retrospective study. The elective orthopaedic surgeries cancelled following their admission into the hospital due to medical reasons between January 2003 and December 2004, were identified. These cases were reviewed using the preoperative assessment charts and case notes. The NHS Modernisation Agency's guidelines, National Good Practice Guidance on Preoperative Assessment for Inpatient Surgery, are taken as the benchmark for comparison.

Findings

The paper finds that 44 elective orthopaedic cases were cancelled due to medical reasons. Of these patients, 64 per cent did not have a pre‐operative assessment prior to the admission for the planned surgery; 6 per cent had inadequate documentation of relevant past medical history; and 30 per cent (patients with significant medical problems) were not referred to the anaesthetist for advice although these problems were identified during the pre‐operative assessment.

Research limitations/implications

It is possible to stimulate good medical practice through audit.

Practical implications

Cancellation of an elective operation is not uncommon in hospital practice. This paper aims to highlight the possible avoidable causes for such cancellations. The paper identifies such deficiencies in the local preoperative assessment protocol and suggests remedies to improve the quality of care. These improvements and close adherence to the guidelines are important as preoperative assessment by nurse‐led clinics are being increasingly practised through out the UK.

Originality/value

The paper fulfils its aims of identifying the medical causes for cancellation of an operation and also the existing deficiencies in the preoperative assessment practice. The paper values the importance of adherence to NHS Modernising Agency's guidelines in preoperative assessment. It is useful not only to the Orthopaedic department but also to the department managers.

Citation

Dussa, C.U., Durve, K. and Singhal, K. (2007), "Cancellations of elective orthopaedic procedures: Compliance with NHS Modernisation Agency guidelines", Clinical Governance: An International Journal, Vol. 12 No. 2, pp. 78-84. https://doi.org/10.1108/14777270710741438