Risk and uncertainty in development: A critical evaluation of using the Monte Carlo simulation method as a decision tool in real estate development projects

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to deal with the appropriateness of using the Monte Carlo simulation as a technique to calculate risk in real estate development.

Design/methodology/approach

The paper is divided into two interlinked segments. The first segment examines the general definition of risk and Monte Carlo simulation methodology as a tool to estimate risk. The second outlines the appropriateness of using Monte Carlo as a tool to model real estate development, given the lack of data quality and its inability to account for human relationships in the development process.

Findings

It is important that the Monte Carlo Simulation model is used as prescriptive model that builds on the original elicitation procedures; produces initial results; allows for detailed sensitivity analysis and then remodels as required. In short, to be fully effective, the Monte Carlo Simulation model needs to be used in a complementary fashion with an understanding of human judgement and decision making.

Research limitations/implications

A fuller analysis may include an examination of the uncertainties in each of the components of the appraisal and account for the appropriate distributions of each of these variables. This is generally referred to as a Monte Carlo simulation. The argument in favour of a Monte Carlo simulation is that it helps the appraiser have a better understanding of the possible outcomes for the development and the relative impact of each input in the pricing of the project.

Practical implications

A lot of work has been done looking at scenario modelling with probabilities and the results that ensue. However, it is important that these quantitative results are placed in the context of the heuristic and cognitive approaches adopted by the decision maker. In other words, the behaviour of the decision maker is as influential in the interpretation of the results as the numbers themselves. This paper looks at the advantages and disadvantages of using Monte Carlo simulation in this context.

Originality/value

This study contributes significantly to the practical application of probability‐based models to development appraisal. The findings of the study are useful for users of feasibility studies to understand the context in which a development feasibility is carried out, and for appraisers to extend the scope of their analysis when carrying them out.

Citation

Loizou, P. and French, N. (2012), "Risk and uncertainty in development: A critical evaluation of using the Monte Carlo simulation method as a decision tool in real estate development projects", Journal of Property Investment & Finance, Vol. 30 No. 2, pp. 198-210. https://doi.org/10.1108/14635781211206922