A study of Russian, Polish, and U.S. self and peer raters: Moderators of rating agreement

Abstract

This study investigates one aspect of the multi‐source feedback process: the agreement between self‐ratings and coworker ratings of workplace behavior. Moderators of rating agreement (i.e., number of years that the coworker had known the employee, trustworthiness of the employee, and country status) are carefully examined. Eighty‐six Russian employee‐coworker dyads, 99 Polish dyads, and 95 U.S. dyads from more than 225 organizations participated. Regression results indicate that rating agreement was higher when the Polish and U.S. coworker knew the target employee a shorter period of time and when the Polish, Russian, and U.S. target employee was considered trustworthy.

Citation

Costigan, R.D., Insinga, R.C., Kranas, G., Ilter, S.S., Kureshov, V.A. and Jason Berman, J. (2005), "A study of Russian, Polish, and U.S. self and peer raters: Moderators of rating agreement", International Journal of Commerce and Management, Vol. 15 No. 3/4, pp. 205-220. https://doi.org/10.1108/10569210580000197