An exploration of managers' reasons for depreciation method choice in Egyptian companies

Abstract

Purpose

This paper aims to complement a more conventional positive accounting theory (PAT)‐based study of accounting method choice in Egyptian firms by examining three alternative computational reasons for depreciation method choice: simplicity; compatibility with industry norm; and suitability for class of asset.

Design/methodology/approach

The paper draws on a questionnaire survey, sent to Egyptian companies, in which managers were asked to indicate their reasons for choosing depreciation methods as well as the actual depreciation methods used.

Findings

The paper finds that technical reasons were frequently given in survey responses from managers. However, the available evidence on the actual depreciation methods used by their firms and industries is in fact more consistent with PAT‐based theories of accounting choice than with such alternatives. This suggests that the responses to the survey reflected managers' rationalisations of decisions made for self‐interested purposes.

Originality/value

Most recent work on managerial decisions concerning accounting choices utilises data gathered from databases of published financial information and is undertaken within a PAT context. This study extends that approach by utilising the results of a questionnaire distributed in Egypt to test some additional hypotheses that reflect possible technical accounting reasons for justifying depreciation methods.

Citation

Dey, C., Grinyer, J., Sinclair, D. and El‐Habashy, H. (2009), "An exploration of managers' reasons for depreciation method choice in Egyptian companies", Journal of Applied Accounting Research, Vol. 10 No. 1, pp. 20-32. https://doi.org/10.1108/09675420910963379