TY - CHAP AB - This chapter examines why the political collapse of Russia and Germany in the end of the First World War resulted in massive expropriation of private property in Russia and consolidation of private property in Germany. This historical divergence is explained by the different measure of coercive capacities of the provisional governments and, consequently, their different ability to withstand the assault of the radical Left during the periods of turbulent political transitions. The measure of coercive capacities was determined primarily by support of the army, which, in turn, was contingent upon the provisional governments’ decisions to negotiate peace and exit the war. VL - 19 SN - 978-0-76231-418-8, 978-1-84950-545-1/0198-8719 DO - 10.1016/S0198-8719(08)19001-9 UR - https://doi.org/10.1016/S0198-8719(08)19001-9 AU - Osinsky Pavel ED - Diane E. Davis ED - Christina Proenza-Coles PY - 2008 Y1 - 2008/01/01 TI - War, state collapse, redistribution: Russian and German revolutions revisited T2 - Political Power and Social Theory T3 - Political Power and Social Theory PB - Emerald Group Publishing Limited SP - 3 EP - 38 Y2 - 2024/04/19 ER -